AI Summary
WordPress.org relaunched a free plugin simply called SMTP in November, 2026. So, should you switch? That’s the WP Mail SMTP vs SMTP plugin question I’ll answer here.
SMTP, the new community-maintained plugin on WordPress.org, gives you 1 generic SMTP connection. WP Mail SMTP adds email APIs, Google and Microsoft sign-in, and backup tools.
In this post, I’ll test and review both plugins to help you make an informed decision when choosing an SMTP plugin to resolve your WordPress email issue. Let’s get started!
WP Mail SMTP vs SMTP: Quick Comparison
The SMTP plugin is enough for basic sending if you already have SMTP credentials. WP Mail SMTP fits if you need SMTP, Microsoft 365 sign-in, an API mailer, or resends.
This table compares the latest versions of both plugins as of the time of this post’s publication.
| Feature | SMTP plugin | WP Mail SMTP |
|---|---|---|
| Mailers | 1 (Generic SMTP) | 15 in Lite, 18 with a paid license |
| Email API mailers | No | Yes (SendLayer, Brevo, Mailgun, and more) |
| Gmail sign-in (OAuth) | No (app password over SMTP) | Yes, in Lite (your own Google app) |
| Microsoft 365 sign-in (OAuth) | No | Yes (license required) |
| Email log | Yes (recipient, subject, status, error) | Yes (license required) |
| Email content in log + resend | No | Yes (license required) |
| Failure alerts | Slack (free) | 8 channels (license required) |
| Backup connection | No | Yes (license required) |
| wp-config constants | Yes | Yes |
| WP-CLI commands | Yes | Yes |
| Support | Community only | Support team + docs |
| Active installs | 700+ | 4,000,000+ |
| Price | Free | Lite free, Paid plan from $49/year |
WP Mail SMTP vs SMTP: The Full Breakdown
The SMTP plugin wins on free logging and Slack alerts. WP Mail SMTP wins on mailers, secure sign-in, email recovery, and support.
Here are the 8 rounds I’ll walk through:
- 1. First Impressions: Who Makes Each Plugin
- 2. Getting Started: Setup and First Test Email
- 3. Connecting Mailers: SMTP vs Email APIs
- 4. Gmail and Microsoft 365: Signing In Safely
- 5. When Emails Fail: Logs, Alerts, and Resend
- 6. For Developers: wp-config and WP-CLI
- 7. Help When You Need It: Support and Docs
- 8. Pricing and Plans
1. First Impressions: Who Makes Each Plugin
Who’s behind a plugin matters, because it tells you who fixes it when email breaks.
SMTP
The WordPress Plugins Team started the SMTP plugin. The community now maintains it on GitHub. It reuses an existing slug from 2011, originally by Serghei Iakovlev and later Sorin Iclanzan.
Many people miss one detail. The announcement says the plugin isn’t part of core. It also says the Plugins Team “doesn’t provide support for it.”
As of the time of writing, its WordPress.org listing shows 700+ active installs and 1 rating. It requires WordPress 6.3 and PHP 7.4. It’s tested up to WordPress 6.9, while the current release is 7.1.


The project also has clear principles. Contributing providers must ship with tests, with no tracking, upsells, or promotional content. I like that stance.
WP Mail SMTP
WP Mail SMTP comes from the WPForms team. With over WordPress.org 4,000,000+ active installs and 5,217 ratings. 4,923 of those are five stars.
There’s a free Lite version on WordPress.org and a paid version with advanced features like backup connection and smart email routing.


First impressions verdict: The SMTP plugin is brand new and community-run, with no official support. WP Mail SMTP has years of use behind it and a team that maintains it. If you want the safer long-term bet, that’s WP Mail SMTP.
2. Getting Started: Setup and First Test Email
How quickly can you go from install to a working test email?
SMTP
Setup lives on one screen under Tools » SMTP. You pick the Generic SMTP provider and fill in a short form:
- Host and Port
- Encryption: None, SSL, or TLS (STARTTLS)
- Authentication checkbox, Username, and Password
- From Email and From Name


Then you open the Test tab and send a test email. The result shows a connection log with your credentials redacted. If it fails, you get a troubleshooting hint.


That’s fast if you already know your host, port, and credentials. If you don’t, the plugin can’t look them up for you.
WP Mail SMTP
WP Mail SMTP starts with a Setup Wizard. It asks which mailer you use and then shows only the fields that mailer needs.


Our Setup Wizard guide covers each screen. A test email tool and Debug Events are both in the free version.
Setup verdict: For someone with SMTP details on hand, the SMTP plugin’s one-page form is quick. For everyone else, WP Mail SMTP’s wizard removes the guesswork.
3. Connecting Mailers: SMTP vs Email APIs
This is the biggest practical gap between the two plugins.
SMTP
The SMTP plugin has 1 built-in provider: Generic SMTP. It sends through PHPMailer over SMTP, and there are no API mailers yet.
The announcement calls API sending “the next big step.” They track it in GitHub issue #1. As of version 1.2.0, it isn’t there.
WP Mail SMTP
WP Mail SMTP Lite 4.10.4 includes 15 mailers:
- Other SMTP (any SMTP server)
- SendLayer, Brevo, Mailgun, SendGrid, and Postmark
- SparkPost, SMTP.com, SMTP2GO, and Elastic Email
- Mailjet, MailerSend, Mandrill, and Resend
- Gmail (with your own Google app)
Pro adds Microsoft 365 / Outlook, Amazon SES, and Zoho Mail.
Most of these connect through the provider’s email API instead of SMTP. That matters because some hosts block SMTP ports. An API connection sidesteps that.


Mailer verdict: If your provider gives you SMTP credentials, both plugins work. Want an API, or does your host block SMTP ports? WP Mail SMTP wins.
4. Gmail and Microsoft 365: Signing In Safely
Can each plugin sign in to Google and Microsoft the secure way?
SMTP
The SMTP plugin has no OAuth sign-in. To use Gmail, you create an app password and enter it as your SMTP password.
That works for Gmail. Microsoft 365 is a different story.
New tenants won’t get basic auth by default either. Microsoft is moving everyone to OAuth, and it plans to announce a final removal date in the second half of 2027.
Microsoft’s announcement has the official timeline. Our guide to Microsoft’s SMTP AUTH changes walks through your options.
WP Mail SMTP
WP Mail SMTP connects to Gmail with OAuth, even in Lite. You set up your own Google app and sign in.
Our Gmail mailer guide covers the steps. Pro adds Gmail one-click setup.
For Microsoft, the Microsoft 365 / Outlook mailer is in Pro. It uses OAuth, so the basic auth change doesn’t affect it. There’s a one-click setup too.


Sign-in verdict: For Gmail, both plugins can work. For Microsoft 365, the SMTP plugin has no answer to the December 2026 change. WP Mail SMTP Pro does.
5. When Emails Fail: Logs, Alerts, and Resend
What happens when an email doesn’t go out? This round is where the SMTP plugin earns real credit.
SMTP
The SMTP plugin’s free version includes an email log. It records the recipient, subject, status, and any error.


It doesn’t store email bodies, headers, or attachments. The plugin deletes entries after 30 days. Since it doesn’t save the content, you can’t resend a failed email.
It also sends failure alerts to Slack for free. Developers can add other channels with the smtp_alert_channels filter.
WP Mail SMTP
WP Mail SMTP Lite has no email log and no failure alerts. You need Pro for both. Lite gives you the test email tool and Debug Events for troubleshooting.
Pro goes further than the SMTP plugin, though. The email log can store full content, so you can resend failed emails. Pro also adds open and click tracking.


Pro sends failure alerts to 8 channels:
- Email and Slack
- Discord and Microsoft Teams
- Twilio SMS and WhatsApp
- Push notifications
- A custom webhook


Our guide on getting alerts when WordPress emails fail covers each setup. Pro also adds a backup connection, smart routing, and email reports. The SMTP plugin has none of these.
Failure handling verdict: The SMTP plugin only supports Slack Alerts, so I’m giving this round to WP Mail SMTP. It includes multiple channels like Slack, Discord, WhatsApp, and more to ensure you don’t miss email failures.
6. For Developers: wp-config and WP-CLI
Both plugins treat developers well, and the SMTP plugin’s tooling is tidy.
SMTP
6 settings have a constant you can set in wp-config.php:
SMTP_HOST
SMTP_PORT
SMTP_ENCRYPTION
SMTP_USER
SMTP_PASSWORD
SMTP_FROM_EMAIL
Constants override the settings screen and lock those fields. The authentication checkbox, From name, and Force from have no constant.
It also ships 3 WP-CLI commands:
wp smtp settings setwp smtp testwp smtp status
The settings command reads the password from STDIN. That keeps it out of your shell history.
The plugin stores the password in its own option, apart from other settings. It never prints it back into the page. Use the SMTP_PASSWORD constant to keep it out of the database entirely.
WP Mail SMTP
WP Mail SMTP also supports constants. You set WPMS_ON to true, then define values like WPMS_MAILER, WPMS_SMTP_HOST, and WPMS_SMTP_PASS. API mailers get their own constants, such as WPMS_SENDLAYER_API_KEY.
Our doc on securing SMTP settings with constants lists them all. Since version 4.9.0, WP Mail SMTP also has WP-CLI commands. Examples include wp wp-mail-smtp test and wp wp-mail-smtp setup.
Developer verdict: It’s close. The SMTP plugin’s short constant list and CLI are clean for single-provider setups. WP Mail SMTP covers more mailers in code.
7. Help When You Need It: Support and Docs
Who do you ask when email stops working?
SMTP
The SMTP plugin is community-supported. The Plugins Team started it, but the team doesn’t provide support for it. Help comes from contributors on GitHub and other users.
To be fair, its test screen does help you help yourself. You get a connection log and a troubleshooting hint when a test fails.
WP Mail SMTP
WP Mail SMTP has a support team and a large docs library. That includes a guide for every mailer and fixes for common errors.
The Elite plan also includes White Glove Setup. Our team configures the plugin for you. You can request White Glove Setup once you’re on Elite.
Support verdict: WP Mail SMTP wins here with its detailed documentation and Expert Advisers in the support team.
8. Pricing and Plans
How much does each plugin cost?
SMTP
The SMTP plugin is free, with no paid version and no upsells.


WP Mail SMTP
WP Mail SMTP Lite is free on WordPress.org. Here’s the starting prices for the available paid plans :
- Pro: $49/year for 1 site
- Elite: $99/year, with White Glove Setup
- Developer: $199/year for 20 sites
- Agency: $399/year for 100 sites


Pricing verdict: Both free plugins have similar features. But the SMTP plugin doesn’t offer what you’d pay for in WP Mail SMTP Pro.
How to Switch From the SMTP Plugin to WP Mail SMTP
You’ll need to move your settings by hand. WP Mail SMTP currently has no native importer for the SMTP plugin. For now, you’ll have to manually move your credentials.
Here’s how to do it:
- Copy your settings. Open Tools » SMTP and note your host, port, encryption, username, and From details. If you used
SMTP_*constants, checkwp-config.php. - Deactivate the SMTP plugin. Keep it installed until your first WP Mail SMTP test succeeds.
- Install WP Mail SMTP and run the Setup Wizard. Pick Other SMTP for the same server. Or choose your provider’s own mailer.


- Send a test email. Use the WP Mail SMTP test email tool. Once it works, you can delete the SMTP plugin.


Need a refresher? Our guide to WordPress SMTP settings explains each field.
My Verdict: Choosing Between WP Mail SMTP and SMTP
Pick the free SMTP plugin for native integration with logging. Pick WP Mail SMTP for Microsoft 365 OAuth, API mailers, resends, or support.
Choose the SMTP plugin if:
- You want a free email log and Slack alerts without paying
Choose WP Mail SMTP if:
- You use Microsoft 365 and need OAuth before December 2026
- You want an API mailer, or your host blocks SMTP ports
- You need to resend failed emails or get alerts beyond Slack
- You want a backup connection and a support team behind you
It fits the same pattern you see across this comparison. The SMTP plugin does one thing cleanly. WP Mail SMTP covers the cases where that one thing isn’t enough.
FAQs — WP Mail SMTP vs SMTP Plugin
Here are quick answers to common questions about these two plugins.
Is the SMTP plugin better than WP Mail SMTP?
No. The SMTP plugin is a good free choice for simple SMTP sending. It’s enough if you don’t need API mailers or OAuth.
WP Mail SMTP adds API mailers, Microsoft 365 sign-in, resend, and backup connections.
Is SMTP an official WordPress plugin?
Not in the sense most people mean. The WordPress Plugins Team started it, but it’s community-maintained on GitHub. It isn’t part of WordPress core, and the Plugins Team doesn’t provide support for it.
Does the SMTP plugin work with Gmail and Microsoft 365?
It works with Gmail if you create an app password and use it over SMTP. It has no OAuth sign-in, though.
At the end of December 2026, Microsoft 365 disables basic auth by default for existing tenants. An admin can re-enable it, but a password-only plugin isn’t a long-term fix.
Can I use WP Mail SMTP and the SMTP plugin together?
No, keep only one active. Both plugins change WordPress’s mailer settings at the same moment, so their settings get mixed.
When we ran both on a test site, emails went to WP Mail SMTP’s server with the SMTP plugin’s login, and they failed. Both plugins also logged every email twice.
What should I look for in a WordPress SMTP plugin?
Start with your email provider. Check that the plugin supports it, ideally through an API or OAuth sign-in. Then look for an email log, failure alerts, and a way to resend failed emails.
Our roundup of the best WordPress SMTP plugins compares the main options.
Next, Set Up the SendLayer Mailer
If you’re switching, the next step is to pick a mailer that sends via an API. I recommend SendLayer.
Our guide to setting up the SendLayer mailer in WP Mail SMTP walks you through it. You’ll connect your domain and send your first test email.
Want a full email log, resend, and Microsoft 365 sign-in? Upgrade to WP Mail SMTP Pro, starting at $49.
Ready to fix your emails? Get started today with the best WordPress SMTP plugin. If you don’t have the time to fix your emails, you can get full White Glove Setup assistance as an extra purchase, and there’s a 14-day money-back guarantee for all paid plans.
If this article helped you out, please follow us on Facebook and Twitter for more WordPress tips and tutorials.
